On January 8, 2019, lawyers for Paul Manafort filed a brief in federal court with several passages blacked out. Within hours, reporters had read every one of them. The black boxes sat on top of the text, and highlighting the area, copying it and pasting it into another document brought the words back.
It keeps happening. In December 2025, people reading the Justice Department’s release of Epstein-related files found that some redactions could be undone the same way, and the New York Times reported that a portion of the blacked-out material was easily recovered. The ABA’s Judges’ Journal has warned about the same failure in columns going back to 2009, and it has caught out law firms, courts and government agencies alike.
None of these cases involved a sophisticated attack. They involved a black shape placed over text that was still there.
Why black boxes fail#
A PDF page is built from layers of objects: text, images and vector shapes, drawn in order. When you draw a black rectangle, you add one more object on top. The text underneath is unchanged. A viewer paints the rectangle over it, so your eye can’t read it, while the file itself still holds every character.
The same thing happens with these common shortcuts:
- black highlighting in Word, then exporting to PDF
- changing the font color to black on black or white on white
- placing an image of a black bar over the text
- using a PDF editor’s shape or comment tool instead of its redaction tool
- cropping a page to hide part of it (the cropped area is still in the file)
- hiding a layer that contains sensitive content
If the text is still in the file, it can be selected, searched, copied or extracted with free software.
What real redaction does#
Proper redaction does two things in order. First, it removes the content from the file: the characters from the text layer, the pixels from any image, and any vector shapes in the marked area. Second, it draws a box where the content used to be, so readers can see that something was withheld.
A complete job also cleans the rest of the file, because sensitive information often appears in places the page doesn’t show: document properties, bookmarks, comments, form fields, attachments, earlier revisions saved inside the file, and the hidden text layer on a scanned page.
How to redact a PDF, step by step#
These steps follow Adobe Acrobat Pro, which most firms use, and the same sequence applies in any dedicated redaction tool.
1. Work on a copy#
Save a copy with a name that marks it as redacted, such as Exhibit 4 - REDACTED.pdf. Keep the original untouched in the matter file. You will need it if a court asks for an unredacted version under seal, and a redaction you can’t undo is easier to trust.
2. Decide what must go#
Make a list before you start: names, account numbers, dates of birth, addresses, medical details, privileged passages, or whatever the rules and your client require. For federal court filings, Rule 5.2 is the baseline. It allows only the last four digits of Social Security numbers, taxpayer ID numbers and financial account numbers, the year of birth, and a minor’s initials.
3. Mark the content with the redaction tool#
Open the Redact tool and mark each item. Use search and redact for anything that repeats, such as a name, an account number or a phone number, so you don’t miss the occurrence on page 47. Most tools also offer patterns for Social Security numbers, phone numbers, email addresses and credit card numbers.
Marking doesn’t remove anything yet. Marked areas usually appear as outlines so you can review them.
4. Review the marks#
Read every page with the marks visible. Look for:
- the same name spelled differently or abbreviated
- information in headers, footers, tables and footnotes
- signatures and handwritten notes on scanned pages
- identifying details in images, such as a license plate or a letterhead
5. Apply the redactions#
Apply the marks. This is the step that removes the content. Acrobat warns you that the change is permanent once you save.
6. Remove hidden information#
Run the sanitize or “remove hidden information” function. It clears metadata, comments, attachments, bookmarks, form data, hidden layers, scripts and earlier versions. Skipping this step is how a correctly redacted page ends up shipped inside a file whose properties, bookmarks or old revision still contain the name.
7. Save as a new file#
Use Save As, not Save, so the tool writes a fresh file instead of appending changes to the old one.
Redacting scanned documents#
A scanned page is a picture. If someone ran OCR on it, there is also an invisible text layer behind the picture so you can search and copy the words. Redacting a scan has to deal with both.
A proper redaction tool removes the pixels in the marked area and the OCR text that sits behind them. A drawn box over a scan covers the picture and leaves the invisible OCR text in place, so search and copy still find the words. After redacting a scan, search for one of the redacted words to confirm it is gone.
Check your work before you send#
Never trust the screen. Run these checks on the final file every time:
- Select all text on each redacted page, copy it and paste it into a plain text editor. Nothing redacted should appear.
- Use the PDF viewer’s search to look for each redacted name or number.
- Open File, then Properties, and read the title, author, subject and keywords.
- Open the bookmarks, comments and attachments panels.
- Check that the file was saved as a new file and contains no earlier revisions.
- Compare redactions across pages, so a name hidden on page 2 isn’t visible on page 9.
- Have a second person spot-check a sample of pages.
An automated check helps with the hidden items people miss. Document Security Check looks for text under black boxes, earlier PDF revisions, comments, author names and other hidden data, and tells you what it found before you file or send.
The one test everyone should know
Highlight the black box, copy, and paste into a blank document. If words appear, the redaction failed. It takes ten seconds, and it would have caught most of the public redaction failures of the last twenty years.
Other ways redactions leak#
Even when the content is removed, information can slip out in quieter ways.
The size of a box can hint at what it covers. A short black bar in a list of names suggests a short name, so for very sensitive material consider boxes of a uniform size.
Context does the rest. Redacting a client’s name while leaving their job title, employer and the date of an unusual event may identify them anyway.
Inconsistent redaction across a production is common in large sets: one document hides a name and a second, unredacted copy of the same email shows it. Search the whole set for each term.
When there is no redaction tool#
If you don’t have Acrobat Pro or another real redaction tool, the safest fallback is to draw opaque boxes, then convert each page to an image, so the boxes are burned into the pixels and no text remains beneath them. Then sanitize the file’s properties and save it as a new file. The result can’t be searched and works poorly with screen readers, so this is a stopgap. For regular work, buy a proper tool.
Building a redaction routine#
Firms that avoid redaction failures treat redaction as a process with a checklist. Give one person ownership of the final check for each filing or production, and keep a short log of what was redacted and why. A redaction log takes minutes and answers the questions that come later, from a court, a client or opposing counsel.
Questions people ask
Can I redact a PDF by drawing a black rectangle?
No. A drawn rectangle is a shape placed on top of the page. The text beneath it stays in the file, and selecting, copying and pasting the area reveals it. Use a redaction tool that removes the underlying content and then applies the box.
Does changing the font color to white or black redact text?
No. The text is still there and can be selected, searched and copied. The same goes for black highlighting in Word.
What should be redacted from a federal court filing?
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.2 limits filings to the last four digits of Social Security and taxpayer ID numbers and financial account numbers, the year of a person's birth, and a minor's initials. Local rules and other procedural rules can add more, so check the rules for your court.
Is it safe to convert a redacted PDF to an image?
Rasterizing a page after drawing opaque boxes burns the boxes into the pixels, so the hidden text can't be copied out. It also makes the document unsearchable and harder for screen readers, so treat it as a fallback when you have no proper redaction tool, and still clean the file's metadata afterward.
Sources
- Embarrassing redaction failures (ABA Judges' Journal, 2019)
- Manafort legal team botches redactions (Atlanta Journal-Constitution, January 8, 2019)
- Redacted material in some Epstein files is easily recovered (New York Times via GV Wire, December 24, 2025)
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.2, Privacy protection for filings made with the court (Cornell LII)
Keep reading
This guide is general information for small firms. It is not legal, insurance or compliance advice for your situation.